Free Speech Lawsuit Against UC Berkeley Upheld by Federal Judge
The lawsuit was filed by two conservative groups after UC Berkeley canceled an appearance by conservative commentator Ann Coulter in 2017.
A federal judge rejected the University of California at Berkeley’s request to dismiss a lawsuit claiming it discriminated against conservative speakers.
Last Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Maxine Chesney ruled that two conservative groups, the Berkeley College Republicans and Young America’s Foundation, could continue to pursue the lawsuit that claims the school imposed unreasonable restrictions and fees on campus appearances by conservative speakers, reports Reuters.
The suit also claims the school applied its policy for handling “major events” and its policy for “high-profile speakers” to unfairly suppress free speech.
The lawsuit lists UC System President Janet Napolitano, UC Berkeley Chancellor Nicholas Dirks and three campus police officials as defendants.
The lawsuit was filed after the university canceled an appearance by conservative political commentator Ann Coulter scheduled for April 27, 2017. Coulter’s planned appearance at the school was arranged by Young America’s Foundation as part of its nationwide campus lecture program.
School officials said they canceled the event “due to the lack of assurances for protections from foreseeable violence from unrestrained leftist agitators.” Officials also say they offered to host the event at a safer location the following week but Coulter refused.
The school’s decision to cancel Coulter’s appearance came just a few months after an appearance by former Breitbart columnist Milo Yiannopoulos was canceled when $100,000 worth of damage was caused by both masked agitators and protesters on campus the night before.
Judge: Plaintiffs Cannot Seek Punitive Damages
While Judge Chesney ruled the lawsuit could be pursued, she also ruled the plaintiffs could not seek punitive damages because she was “unpersuaded” by their claims that the school engaged in intentional viewpoint discrimination and that its major events policy was too vague.
The major events policy was adopted by the school in July and gives school officials the option to take various steps to ensure security at campus events.
Chesney says the plaintiffs may pursue an equal protection claim over a security fee charged for an appearance by conservative speaker Ben Shapiro that was almost double the fee at the same venue to host Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor.
Chesney also upheld the school’s contention that it was motivated by security, not liberal bias, when it scheduled talks by other conservative speakers in smaller and more remote campus locations, according to LMT Online.
UC Berkeley released a statement Thursday following the decision, calling the $9,000 fee charged for Shapiro’s appearance “lawful and appropriate.” UC Berkeley spokesman Dan Mogulof said the university could defend the security fee since the school spent more than $800,000 on safety measures for the speech.
The statement also said the school is pleased with Chesney’s ruling to uphold its major events policy and her denial that the school had a “secret” policy for high-profile speakers.
Harmeet Dhillon, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, also said she was pleased with the decision.
“It is good news that the case is going forward,” she said. “The First Amendment is a core constitutional principle, and every government policy that restricts, censors or bars otherwise legal speech is unconstitutional.”
If you appreciated this article and want to receive more valuable industry content like this, click here to sign up for our FREE digital newsletters!
Leading in Turbulent Times: Effective Campus Public Safety Leadership for the 21st Century
This new webcast will discuss how campus public safety leaders can effectively incorporate Clery Act, Title IX, customer service, “helicopter” parents, emergency notification, town-gown relationships, brand management, Greek Life, student recruitment, faculty, and more into their roles and develop the necessary skills to successfully lead their departments. Register today to attend this free webcast!