Vests Past Their Prime
What do you do with your used ballistic vest?
Guidelines from the National Institute of Justice call for manufacturer warranties on ballistic vests to last five years. This means over the course of a career in law enforcement you could easily wind up going through four or five yourself. When your body armor warranty expires and you receive a new vest, what do you do with the old one? From recycling to repurposing, there are multiple options depending on your agency’s policies and resources.
It used to be fairly common to pass on older ballistic vests to law enforcement agencies in the United States and abroad that didn’t have enough money to purchase their own new body armor. But this is no longer as common because of liability concerns.
“I would not give, sell, or offer any used body armor, for I would fear a claim of the vests being out of date or of our providing less than safe equipment,” says Chief William L. Harvey of the Ephrata (Pa.) Police Department. “I am just lawsuit weary after too many years as a chief.” Harvey has also turned down requests by parents of soldiers to send used ballistic panels overseas to the military for the same reasons. “Again, I worry about the implied liability,” he says.
The Orange County (Fla.) Sheriff’s Office has even been wary of requests from local judges that want to use ballistic panels to line desks in their chambers for added protection from criminals.
Other factors come into play as well. When body armor is sold to a police department, it is contracted for and delivered directly to that agency and each vest is fitted specifically for the intended recipients. After their initial use, not only might the vests have suffered wear and tear, but if a vest does not fit the secondary wearer well it will not provide the same protection. Then there is the concern of body armor falling into the wrong hands somewhere along the way.
“We want to make sure armor isn’t ending up in any felon’s hands, or someone who doesn’t understand what the vest is or is not capable of,” explains Jeff Fackler, North American marketing and product manager for DuPont.
For these very reasons, some body armor manufacturers will collect an agency’s vests that are past warranty and destroy them on a limited basis.
“From time to time, we’ve collected used vests from police agencies at little or no charge to the department,” says Matt Davis, president and CEO of Armor Express. “The vests are then disassembled and cut into scrap at our factory. Most vests today are hybrid constructions utilizing multiple ballistic materials. Some materials have ‘scrap value’ and can be sold to recyclers, but other materials have no value and have to be discarded.”
Disposing of ballistic vests is a costly enterprise, whether simply destroying them so they can’t be used for nefarious purposes or dismantling them for scrap. Therefore manufacturers and distributors can’t destroy vests on a regular basis. There just isn’t a sustainable system in place.
“This is something we’re attending to. It’s a need in the industry,” says Fackler.
Alternatively, agencies can work with independent contractors to destroy vests and or to recycle the materials. According to Sgt. Carlos Nieves, the New York Police Department works with a contractor to destroy any vests it doesn’t send back to the manufacturer.
“The first part for a department looking to use a recycling program is they do need to work with someone who’s reputable and can provide documentation,” says Fackler.
The same holds true for companies that specialize in destroying vests. If you’re unsure of where to begin, contact other agencies and even body armor manufacturers for recommendations.