Conservative Commentator Loses Free-Speech Lawsuit Against UMN

The judge ruled UMN’s solution to its security concerns over Ben Shapiro’s speech was a “content-neutral place restriction in furtherance of public safety.”

Conservative Commentator Loses Free-Speech Lawsuit Against UMN

Ben Shapiro’s lawsuit against the University of Minnesota (UMN) has been thrown out by a judge who found that the school’s move of his speech to a more rural campus was motivated by safety concerns, not politics.

The conservative speaker, along with two student groups, sued several UMN officials who helped plan the logistics of Shapiro’s 2018 speech.

Shapiro alleged that these officials discriminated against his viewpoint by moving his event to a ballroom on the St. Paul campus that holds 450 people, reports The venue that was provided by the university was a 15-minute shuttle ride from the main campus, reports

The judge ruled, however, that UMN had legitimate security concerns over Shapiro’s speech. U.S. District Judge Susan Richard Nelson cited the fact that previous presentations by the conservative speaker at other universities, including those at UC Berkeley and the University of Wisconsin, had attracted hundreds of protestors. The judge ruled the solution UMN provided was a “content-neutral place restriction in furtherance of public safety.”

In court documents, UMN said it chose the St. Paul site rather than the Willey site because Willey had skyway access that could make it harder to manage protestors, reports

The student leader of the group that sponsored Shapiro’s event agreed to the venue selection and did not let UMN know the group didn’t want the speech to be in St. Paul. UMN only found out about Shapiro’s and his conservative sponsors’ dissatisfaction with the venue after the event sold out.

The school spent about $15,000 on security.

At this summer’s Campus Safety Online Summit, UC Berkeley Police Chief Margot Bennett discussed the valuable lessons her department learned from the high-profile protests and demonstrations her campus has experienced and the subsequent policies that were developed for similar future events. Read the article about lessons her department has learned.

If you appreciated this article and want to receive more valuable industry content like this, click here to sign up for our FREE digital newsletters!

About the Author

robin hattersley headshot

Robin has been covering the security and campus law enforcement industries since 1998 and is a specialist in school, university and hospital security, public safety and emergency management, as well as emerging technologies and systems integration. She joined CS in 2005 and has authored award-winning editorial on campus law enforcement and security funding, officer recruitment and retention, access control, IP video, network integration, event management, crime trends, the Clery Act, Title IX compliance, sexual assault, dating abuse, emergency communications, incident management software and more. Robin has been featured on national and local media outlets and was formerly associate editor for the trade publication Security Sales & Integration. She obtained her undergraduate degree in history from California State University, Long Beach.

Leading in Turbulent Times: Effective Campus Public Safety Leadership for the 21st Century

This new webcast will discuss how campus public safety leaders can effectively incorporate Clery Act, Title IX, customer service, “helicopter” parents, emergency notification, town-gown relationships, brand management, Greek Life, student recruitment, faculty, and more into their roles and develop the necessary skills to successfully lead their departments. Register today to attend this free webcast!

One response to “Conservative Commentator Loses Free-Speech Lawsuit Against UMN”

  1. RL Steel says:

    Thrown out is different from losing… If you haven’t been given a chance to argue your case – you haven’t actually “lost the case” – very misleading headline.

    I remember when law makers wouldn’t let the Jackson’s play at Foxboro Stadium for “fear” of the same reason- ridiculous

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get Our Newsletters
Campus Safety HQ